Talent Recap

10 ‘Got Talent’ Singers Who Proved Simon Cowell Wrong

Simon Cowell and Souparnika NairTalent Recap via YouTube

As the critical music mogul that he is, Simon Cowell is never afraid of rejecting a talent if he doesn’t see them fit in the industry. Thus, when he denies a vocal ability, artists must take it as a chance to prove him wrong.

We compiled 10 singing auditions that Simon Cowell didn’t love in the beginning. Here are the artists who dared to change his mind about their skill and became successful in doing so.

1. Souparnika Nair

Souparnika Nair was a 10-year-old singer who originally sang to “Trolley Song” by Judy Garland during her audition Britain’s Got Talent on series 14. Unimpressed, Cowell asked her to perform another song, and there she belted “Never Enough” by Loren Allred. What happened next was amazing.

2. Ansley Burns

Singing “Think” by Aretha Franklin, Ansley Burns tried to shoot her shot 0n America’s Got Talent season 14. Apparently, Cowell would like to hear her voice without any background track. Nervous at first but determined to get in, Burns did what was asked of her and awed the audience afterwards.

3. Shaheen Jafargholi

Shaheen Jafargholi was aged twelve whens he auditioned for Britain’s Got Talent series 3. He tried to get yeses by singing to “Valerie” by Amy Winehouse, but Cowell harshly commented that his song choice was wrong. Jafargholi then decided to sing “Who’s Lovin’ you” by Michael Jackson, ultimately reaching Cowell’s standard.

4. Daniel Emmet

Daniel Emmet attempted to get the judges’ nods with his original song “Amante,” but that only propelled Cowell to stop his AGT season 13 audition. The mogul asked if he has a backup song which he didn’t have, so Cowell tasked him to study Il Divo’s “Passera” backstage. Emmet took the challenge and came back, finally getting Cowell’s approval.

5. Scarlett Lee

Scarlett Lee auditioned for the The X Factor season 15 with her self-written song “Survival.” However, Cowell interrupted her in the middle of her performance and dared her to sing another song. She decided to sing Loren Allred’s “Never Enough” which earned her a loud applause and four yeses.

6. Jimmie Herrod

Jimmie Herrod came to audition for America’s Got Talent season 16, not knowing that he’s going to sing the “worst song in the world,” at least according to Cowell. Nevertheless, despite the risk, Herrod proceeded to sing “Tomorrow” from the musical Annie as he doesn’t have a second song prepared. After the performance, Cowell admitted that “Tomorrow” didn’t seem so bad anymore.

7. Joseph McCaul

Joseph McCaul is an Irish singer who had a messy start on the first attempt of his audition on The X Factor season 12. Thus, when the judges gave him another chance, it wasn’t his to waste. He subsequently performed Whitney Houston’s “I Wanna Dance With Somebody,” successfully making it to the next round.

8. Cristina Rae

Initially singing “In The Air Tonight” by Phil Collins, Cristina Rae failed to impress Cowell in her AGT season 15 audition. Nevertheless, the music mogul seemed to have seen potential and asked her to sing a different song. She then belted “Gimme Shelter” by The Rolling Stones, consequently securing a Golden Buzzer from Heidi Klum.

9. Sian Pattison

It was Sian Pattison’s daughter that originally sent an application on her behalf because she was extremely nervous about joining the competition. In the midst of her BGT series 11 audition, Cowell cut her off and told her that her song choice wasn’t right. She then performed “With You” from Ghost: The Musical, proving her daughter right for signing her up.

10. Connor Johnson

Entering America’s Got Talent season 17 armed with his voice and guitar, Connor Johnson sang “Forever” by Lewis. Unluckily, Cowell found this boring and stopped him halfway through the performance. The music mogul demanded to hear something else so he gave him “Latch” by Disclosure.

Let us know what you feel about this article

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Calling all Talent Enthusiasts!

Subscribe to the Talent Recap Newsletter for all Talent News, and/or subscribe to our EXCLUSIVE America's Got Talent Newsletter for all the latest AGT Scoop!

Enter your email address in the box below, click "Subscribe", and find the latest news delivered to your inbox weekly. Be prepared to experience the thrill, the drama, and the sheer talent that all of these shows have to offer!
Choose the news YOU want
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x